Nationwide, home insurance premium revenue rose 59% from 2021 to 2025, more than twice the 28% increase in claims payouts.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contacts:
Jarice Thompson, Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, jarice@ourfinancialsecurity.org
Kenny Stancil, Revolving Door Project, stancil@therevolvingdoorproject.org
Patrick Davis, Public Citizen, pdavis@citizen.org
U.S. home insurers took in an estimated $113 billion in excess underwriting profit from 2021 through 2025, according to a new joint report from Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, Revolving Door Project, and Public Citizen.
Drawing on data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the report, Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis, shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, increased cost of reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for. The report also highlights at the state level how much climate adaptation could be paid for with the industry’s ill-gotten gains.
Key Findings
- Less of each premium dollar went back to policyholders. In 2025, insurers paid about 55 cents in claims for every dollar they collected in premiums, down from 69 cents in 2021. For reference, home insurance loss ratios averaged 74 percent in the 1990s.
- Many claims went unpaid or took months to resolve. From 2021 through 2025, insurers closed about 30% of claims without payment. Of the claims they paid, more than 22% were paid after 60 days.
- Rate increases continued even where claims payouts fell. The report examines Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine, and Florida. In Texas, insurers collected 78% more in premiums in 2025 than in 2021, while claims payouts fell 23%. Over the same period, Liberty Mutual’s largest home insurance company in Texas increased its rates by a cumulative 144%, with little objection from the state regulator.
- The industry made $113 billion in excess underwriting income. If regulators set minimum loss ratios at 80%, similar to federal requirements for health insurers, underwriting income from 2021 to 2025 would have been reduced by an estimated $113 billion—money that could have stayed in homeowners’ and renters’ pockets.
“Home insurers are simultaneously overcharging and short-changing households as the fossil fuel-driven climate crisis intensifies,” said Kenny Stancil, deputy research director at the Revolving Door Project. “Relentlessly hiking rates and denying ever more claims has enabled insurance companies to generate billions of dollars in excess underwriting income, which they waste on lavish CEO pay packages and endless ads, and funnel into financial markets to boost investment returns for shareholders. Public officials must use every tool at their disposal to curb industry profiteering and insist that these ill-gotten gains be used instead to help communities adapt to increasingly frequent and severe weather.”
“Insurance companies are maximizing profits by raising rates, withdrawing from communities, and closing a staggering number of claims without payment,” said Elyse Schupak, policy advocate with Public Citizen’s Climate Program. “After spending years pointing to climate change and rising disaster costs to justify offering policyholders less protection at a higher price, the insurance industry is reaping record profits. Insurance companies preach about protecting households, but the numbers reveal that the industry is actively padding its bottom line at their expense.
“Families are paying too much for home insurance and getting less back when climate disasters strike. In 2025, insurers paid just 55 cents in claims for every dollar they collected in premiums, far below the historical average of 70 to 80 cents in the 1990s,” said Alex Martin, climate finance policy director at Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund. “Insurance regulators and policymakers at every level of government should take action now to stop families from being forced to pay more for less.”
Along with these findings, the report also includes policy recommendations that prioritize climate adaptation and transparency for consumers: Strengthening oversight of insurer rate increases and considering loss ratio trends, requiring insurers to invest in and reward climate resilience, and increasing transparency over insurer underwriting, pricing, and claim decisions are among the report recommendations to address the industry’s profiteering.
Read the full report here.
###
Photo: A roof is replaced in Everett, Washington. Taken in September 2018 by Cindy Shebley and licensed under CC BY 2.0.